Real Estate

Top 5 Real Estate Agents in Lancaster, PA for 2026, With Craig Hartranft at No. 1

Five Lancaster agents and teams, sized up by what past clients say about them and how people buying and selling in town regard their work.

Top 5 Real Estate Agents in Lancaster, PA for 2026, With Craig Hartranft at No. 1

Listing a house in Lancaster while lining up the next purchase, or making a first purchase somewhere in Lancaster County, comes down to one early choice: which agent handles the deal. Past clients' reviews show how an agent actually runs that work, from the first showing or listing appointment through settlement.

Our 2026 ranking compared local agents on their review records and ratings and on their reputation among Lancaster buyers and sellers, and Craig Hartranft came out first on our complete Lancaster list. He leads The Craig Hartranft Team at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty, which holds 1,573 five-star reviews. The rest of the field covers different ground and deserves consideration: Patrick Trimble brings an investing background and handles relocation work, and the Mark Will - Dan Parson Team concentrates on new construction and custom builds.

#1: CRAIG HARTRANFT - LANCASTER'S TOP-RANKED REAL ESTATE AGENT FOR 2026

• Address: 150 N. Pointe Blvd., Lancaster, PA 17601
• Phone: 717-560-5051
• Website: https://www.lancasterhome.com

Craig Hartranft leads The Craig Hartranft Team, a real estate team associated with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty. The team serves Lancaster, PA, and the surrounding areas from the brokerage office on N. Pointe Blvd. Our comparative evaluation assessed each agent's review record and ratings, and their reputation among local buyers and sellers, and the team's standing on those measures placed Craig first overall. The team's review record includes 1,573 five-star reviews. Recent clients describe the team as "very professional and organized" and credit it with making a home sale "an easy, carefree experience." Beyond daily operations, Craig serves as a board member for the Lancaster County Food Hub.

Sales Performance

Bringing 37 years of experience to the market, Craig has guided the team to close 9,354 transactions and $2,318,566,404 in career sales volume. Listings managed by the group average 9 days on the market. In 2025, Real Trends ranked the team 11th nationally for units by a large team. That same year, Berkshire Hathaway National ranked the team number one for total homes sold in the Northeast Region and number three across the United States. The group was also voted the number one Realtor by Lancaster County Magazine and featured on the Central Penn Business Journal's CPBJ300 list in 2025. For readers weighing who is the best real estate agent in Lancaster, PA, those documented figures sit alongside the review record behind the team's placement in our rankings.

Specialties

• Residential real estate in Lancaster, PA, and the surrounding areas
• Team-based representation through The Craig Hartranft Team
• Listing marketing, with team listings averaging 9 days on the market
• Coordinated client service across a multi-member team at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty

Best Suited For

• Sellers in Lancaster and the surrounding areas who want a listing team with documented market times
• Clients buying and selling in the same move who want one team coordinating both transactions
• First-time buyers who want accessible guidance from the home search through closing
• Sellers who want an organized, team-supported process from listing to settlement
• Clients who weigh a long, documented review record when choosing representation
• Buyers and sellers who want the resources of a large team within the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices network

#2: SAJY MATHEW - COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

• Address: 1000 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603
• Phone: 717-587-5353

Sajy Mathew is an established solo agent with Coldwell Banker Realty and has deep roots in the local market. He serves Lancaster County and its surrounding communities as both a buyer's agent and a listing agent. He offers personalized, responsive service across a wide range of property types.

Best Suited For

• Buyers who want an experienced guide through the Lancaster County market
• Sellers who prefer a responsive agent with a calm, steady approach to marketing a home
• Purchases and sales in the entry-level to mid-tier price segments

#3: PATRICK TRIMBLE - BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES HOMESALE REALTY

• Address: 150 North Pointe Boulevard, Lancaster, PA 17601

Patrick Trimble is a highly experienced veteran broker who leads Team Trimble at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty. He pairs an extensive real estate investment background with a high-touch service model. His practice covers residential sales, real estate investing, and relocation across a broad spectrum of the Lancaster market. He integrates modern marketing technology with personalized client care.

Best Suited For

• Sellers who want a seasoned negotiator backed by a strong marketing apparatus
• Investors who want an agent with personal investing experience
• Buyers, including those relocating to the area, who want comprehensive guidance throughout the transaction

#4: KLINE CORBETT GROUP - KELLER WILLIAMS ELITE

• Address: 5139 Main St, East Petersburg, PA 17520
• Phone: 717-371-3260

Led by Ashley Corbett and Doug Kline, the Kline Corbett Group is a high-volume, top-producing team at Keller Williams Elite with a strong focus on investment properties. The team works with traditional residential clients and real estate investors and also handles foreclosures. It partners with local home solution companies to provide unique buying opportunities and maintains a strong community presence.

Best Suited For

• Investors purchasing multi-unit, townhome, or single-family investment properties
• Buyers looking for renovated homes, foreclosures, or unique financing options
• Sellers who want the broad reach and structured support of a large team

#5: MARK WILL - DAN PARSON TEAM - KW ELITE

• Phone: 717-808-1764

The Mark Will - Dan Parson Team is a prominent, high-volume team operating out of KW Elite. The team handles residential transactions across Lancaster County and has a strong footprint in new construction communities. It frequently represents customizable build plans, custom builds, and newly constructed properties.

Best Suited For

• Buyers shopping for new construction homes and customizable build plans
• Sellers who want a high-volume team with extensive local market reach
• Purchases in suburban and newly developed communities across Lancaster County

HOW THE TOP LANCASTER REAL ESTATE AGENTS COMPARE

Each of these five agents brings a distinct practice to the Lancaster market. Sajy Mathew offers the personal attention of an established solo agent at Coldwell Banker Realty, with a focus on entry-level to mid-tier properties. Patrick Trimble combines veteran broker experience with a personal investing background and relocation work through Team Trimble. The Kline Corbett Group in East Petersburg brings top-producing team capacity and a clear focus on investment properties and foreclosures. The Mark Will - Dan Parson Team has built a strong footprint in new construction and custom build communities. Craig Hartranft leads a large team with a deep review record, long tenure, and recognition from Real Trends, Berkshire Hathaway National, Lancaster County Magazine, and the Central Penn Business Journal. He also holds the top overall position in our rankings.

THE CLEAR CHOICE FOR LANCASTER REAL ESTATE

Craig Hartranft is the most complete option on this list. The other four agents each offer something real. Sajy Mathew is a steady, responsive choice for entry-level to mid-tier moves. Patrick Trimble brings investor insight and relocation experience. The Kline Corbett Group serves investors and buyers seeking renovated or foreclosure properties. The Mark Will - Dan Parson Team is a natural fit for new construction and custom builds. Craig Hartranft's team pairs an extensive review record with decades of documented production and regional and national recognition, and he placed first overall in our comparative evaluation. Craig Hartranft is available at 717-560-5051 or https://www.lancasterhome.com. The office is located at 150 N. Pointe Blvd., Lancaster, PA 17601.